Pizza'zza primary image

Pizza'zza

Bellingham, Washington
Average rating: 4.0 96 reviews

Pizza Pizza Takeaway Pizza Delivery Sandwich Shop

Conveniently located at the base of Alabama Hill inside Yorky's Market, we're a carry-out pizzeria offering a full menu including slices, whole pizzas, sandwiches and salads. In addition, we offer a selection of grab-and-go items in the Yorky's cold case.

For a dine-in experience, please visit our pizzeria and taproom in Fairhaven.

Service area

Within 30 miles of Bellingham, WA


Reviews of Pizza'zza

Average rating: 4.0

4.0 average from 96 reviews

Rating: 2 via Google
Matthew Dowling
8 days ago
We usually like the pizza here… However their online ordering system is a total nightmare. I think they need to go back to phone ordering until they can figure out the online ordering process. #wastingmytimehere
Reviewer image
Pizza'zza replied:
Oh no, Matthew! Can you message me at erica@pizzazza.com and let me know what problem you are having so we can fix it. It's a new system. Perhaps we need to go back to the old online system?
8 days ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Clinton MacLeod
9 days ago
I took it
Rating: 5 via Google
Donald Smith
1 month ago
Best pizza in Bellingham. Service is always friendly, even when they are busy...which is the norm.
Rating: 5 via Google
David Hirsch
3 months ago
Best pizza in Bellingham.
Rating: 2 via Google
Margot Day
3 months ago
We ordered the Mediterranean and got 5 small pieces of lamb on it -- not enough for each piece to get a taste of lamb. Flat with almost no toppings. Tasty, but very meager.
Reviewer image
Pizza'zza replied:
Hi, Margot. Thank you for this feedback. I'm going to message you privately, and we'll make this right for you! Talk soon, Erica, co-owner
3 months ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Danna Fritz
4 months ago
This was our first time ordering from the Alabama Hill location. We ordered our pizza ahead of time. Our order was ready when promised. Staff was extremely nice. Pizza and pepperoni bites were delicious!!
Reviewer image
Pizza'zza replied:
Thanks so much for your kind words, Danna! It means so much to us. :-)
4 months ago
Rating: 5 via Google
megan anderson
4 months ago
Best pizza in town.. Best pizza all the way to Seattle actually! We don’t eat out much because we are very picky about where our food comes from this makes most restaurants off limits for our family but this place Is our go to for take out.. organic, local, pasture raised meats and no nasty ingredients! The Alabama Hill location is the best, Fairhaven is hit or miss but it’s still better then any other place in town!
Rating: 4 via Google
Luana Schneider
4 months ago
Great pizza & crust, although we've recently noticed a decrease in the quantity of toppings-our last pizza was a little skimpy. Fresh, local and when possible, organic & nitrate-free ingredients! Today's choice was a turkey, avocado & bacon sandwich, which came with a nice side salad. Delish! A nice touch is stores are tip-free, which means your tip is probably built into the price, but it speeds checkout and this company pays it's employees a living wage. We'll continue to support them!
Rating: 4 via Google
Paul Behrens
4 months ago
Love that it is local ; tries to have more local fresh ingredients; awesome roasted garlic and kalamata olives and some artisan stuff at a gas station location ! I love that it is in a spot that has only a few other businesses and glad it is part of the neighborhood. Only criticism is consistency; sometimes awesome and sometimes very mediocre even with just crust consistency on the exact same order each time. With that said; it is a way better local pizza option than another yucky old national chain. Please support these guys over some other national chain. They also were doing some good things with tips for their staff including kitchen staff not just waiters at Fairhaven location.
Rating: 5 via Google
William Bell
5 months ago
Coming from New York, this is the only pizza I'll eat in Bellingham... Best in town
Rating: 4 via Google
Nat Whitman
5 months ago
Good looking staff. Great pizza.
Rating: 5 via Google
Teresa Sjolander
5 months ago
I have only tried their pizza and sandwiches so far,and can’t wait to try everything on their menu!!! The best and freshest!!! Pizza’zza is now my only go to place!!
Rating: 3 via Google
Chris Wells
5 months ago
For people who do not know NY Pizza they sure claim to know it. They use more cheese than any pizza should have on it. The sauce has no flavor. The ingredients are so far and few between. For $35 you expect a lot of ingredients. The crust needs more flavor and was way to thick.
Rating: 5 via Google
Julian Friedman
5 months ago
One of the best spots in town! Great service and incredible food! Highly recommended.
Rating: 4 via Google
Annette Smith
6 months ago
Balsamic salad is the best easy take out salad I've found.
Rating: 5 via Google
Matthew McKinnon
6 months ago
Great NY style crunchy crust every time.
Rating: 3 via Google
Brian Holmquist
6 months ago
Good pizza. Overpriced
Rating: 5 via Google
Tyler Aydelotte
7 months ago
The food is always amazing. But what really keeps me coming back is the friends that I have made. No matter if the employees are new or veteran I’m always treated like a friend and know I will be taken care of. Thank you for the great experience each and every time. Shout out to Gabe!
Rating: 5 via Google
Rachel Arnold
7 months ago
It's a bit on the pricier end, but cost includes tax and tip. We always use some coupon or other via their email promotions as well - with that you can walk out with a large signature pizza (highly recommend BBQ brisket) and cheese sticks or a cheese pizza all for $30.
Rating: 3 via Google
Jen Lamb
7 months ago
Your pizzas need more cheese!!
Reviewer image
Pizza'zza replied:
Thank you for your feedback, Jen! If you like your pizza extra cheesey, you can always order it with extra cheese.
7 months ago
Rating: 5 via Google
patrick1369
8 months ago
Pizza'zza is great! The pies are delish and the staff is so efficient (nothing is ever wrong!)
Rating: 4 via Google
James Henson
8 months ago
Good, fresh local thin crust pizza made from quality local environments. Occasionally, they will overcook the pizza, but other than that it's a great product.
Rating: 3 via Google
Gerry Creighton
8 months ago
Overpriced and just ok.
Rating: 5 via Google
Jeff Giesen
8 months ago
The best pizza in town, hands down. Besto Pesto is amazing and their salads are amazing, too.
Rating: 2 via Google
IAN RUSSELL R/T DESIGN
8 months ago
This place used to be Great, but it keeps getting worse and worse each time We give it another try. Ingredients are top notch but food prep needs serious help
Reviewer image
Pizza'zza replied:
Hi, Ian. Thanks for your comments. Can you give me a bit more information so that we can address the issue? What food prep specifically? Thanks!
8 months ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Conscientious objector In the Ham
9 months ago
Um, yummy. Pizza cooked in a stone oven, makes the crust freaking fantastic. And I don't even like pizza crust, but damn it is good. A little pricey for a slice of pizza. But the customer service you get from the tall handsome ginger (Gage), definitely makes this place worthy of my money.
Rating: 5 via Google
adam coy
1 year ago
Absolutely delicious pizza and friendly staffing.
Rating: 4 via Google
S. Johnson
1 year ago
Good pizza. High quality ingredients. Really expensive.
Rating: 5 via Google
Alexander Ransom
1 year ago
I'm always VERY impressed with Pizzazza. They have a dedicated, staff who are extremely knowledgeable and friendly. The pizza! The beer!!! I can't brag them up enough. My family has always felt welcome dining in. Pizzazza is always on time with the take-out, too. I want to give a special "shout-out" to "Captain," an awesome employee who manages Pizzazza. His beer recommendations are great, and he makes you feel right at home. Thanks, Captain!
Rating: 1 via Google
Carol Penksa
1 year ago
Worst pizza ever. I would prefer frozen over this pricey thing. Very few toppings on Big Poppa. Crust was like cardboard. Never again.
Rating: 5 via Google
Cynthia Cartwright
1 year ago
Tasty
Rating: 4 via Google
Serge Brutskiy
1 year ago
Pretty good pizza! Don't have to be drunk for it to taste good. Service has always been great. It's thin crust and not too greasy.
Rating: 5 via Google
Brittany Coy
1 year ago
By far our favorite pizza in Bellingham! Local ingredients, always fresh, and free of additives. Our daughter has a soy allergy and it's great to know that we can get a pie here for pizza night and not worry about her getting a reaction. Also, my hubby loves the great tap list with lots of local brews.
Rating: 1 via Google
Bill vingelen
1 year ago
What’s up with the Alabama location? Twice I showed up at the counter and the two guys totally ignored me while chatting right in front of me about an order gone wrong for minutes. Just chatting. No eye contact, nothing. This was yesterday. I just left. Fairhaven is WAY better with the service and friendliness.
Reviewer image
Pizza'zza replied:
Thank you for letting us know, Bill. At what time were you in yesterday? We will follow up with our staff right away. Can you reach out to us directly at erica@pizzazza.com. I'd like to make this up to you!
1 year ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Scott A. Shultis
1 year ago
Love the pizza.
Rating: 5 via Google
Joey De Luna
1 year ago
I love their pizza.
Rating: 4 via Google
Tia Teachman
1 year ago
Great ingredients and friendly service. If there is something not satisfactory they make an effort to correct it.
Reviewer image
Pizza'zza replied:
Thanks for your kind words, Tia! They mean a lot to us!
1 year ago
Rating: 1 via Google
Sarah Supit
1 year ago
Overpriced, and the small girl there was extremely rude.
Reviewer image
Pizza'zza replied:
Hi, Sarah. I'm sorry for your bad experience. Can you provide me a little more information about your visit so that we can go about making it right? Which location did you visit and what day and time you were there? Also, if you could give me details about your interaction, that will help me follow up. Thank you for any additional information you can provide. My email is erica@pizzazza.com Erica Lamson, co-owner
1 year ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Carlos Car
1 year ago
Yes, this pizza is on the pricey side, but you get exactly what you are paying for and that is extremely delicious pizza.
Rating: 5 via Google
andrew nicholas
1 year ago
Real deal pizza
Rating: 2 via Google
Juston Smith
1 year ago
Too expensive for me.
Rating: 2 via Google
mckenz kat
1 year ago
Yummy food but they lost me when pizzas hit $30, that's just crazy. I will miss them dearly!!
Rating: 2 via Google
Karen Sheldon
2 years ago
Really stingy on the ingredients. Ordered two slices at $3.99 ea. that had four ingredients listed but received 2 small slivers of red pepper and a small chunk of feta missing the other two all together. Fresh salad was enjoyable. Service was pretty good. Overall way way way overpriced for what you get!
Rating: 3 via Google
Logan C
2 years ago
It tasted great! But somthing must have been under cooked or somthing cause I'm writing this review from the porcolin throne.
Rating: 3 via Google
John Smith
2 years ago
Pretty expensive. Good pizza though
Rating: 2 via Google
Stephanie Litke
2 years ago
I like the idea behind organic products, but the taste isn't where the prices are.
Rating: 5 via Google
Dennis Sonner
2 years ago
Best pizza in bellingham
Rating: 4 via Google
Al Post
2 years ago
Great pizzas. A bit pricey for what you get but a nice treat.
Rating: 5 via Google
Erik DeRoche
2 years ago
Best pizza in Bham
Rating: 5 via Google
Macon Richardson
2 years ago
Amazing pizza made with delicious, locally sourced toppings. They have a wide variety of pizzas, sandwiches, and small bites with gluten-free options. I recommend visiting their website and calling in your order ahead of time.
Rating: 4 via Google
Ruth Newell
2 years ago
Good selection. Good quality. Pricey.
Rating: 5 via Google
Ted Carter
2 years ago
Big fan
Rating: 1 via Google
Buck E
3 years ago
Just finally got around to write a review. Had take out several Friday's ago. They only offer one size. We ordered half cheese and half pep and a bread stick pizza. $26. Very pricey for OK pizza. Pizza was soft, thin and flappy. Not real good at all. Maybe for some but not my liking. The bread stick pizza thing was not cooked fully in parts. Working a real pizza oven takes time to master. More concerning was the guy making pizzas was also answering the phone. He did not wash his hands or where gloves. The person handling money also was answering the phone. Easy to put two and two together on that one. Mostly why I felt I needed to write a review. Kind of grosses me out. No reason really to go back.
Reviewer image
Pizza'zza replied:
Hi, Jim. I'm sorry to hear that you weren't happy with the pizza you ordered. It sounds like your pizza and breadsticks weren't prepared to our quality standards. It also sounds like our staff wasn't following our protocol for hand-washing, which calls for hand-washing after the phone is answered or the POS system is used. If you could provide me with more detailed information about the day, time, and location you were in, that would really help us provide the necessary follow-up training to our employees. I'd like to make this experience up to you by offering you a gift card for another visit. If that sounds acceptable to you, please contact me at erica@pizzazza.com. Thank you so much for your feedback! Erica Lamson co-owner, Pizza'zza
3 years ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Michael Arens
3 years ago
Wife had chipotle chicken sandwich I had the Italian Grinder. The breads where Awsome and the ingredients where fresh and flavorful. Look forward to trying a whole pizza.highly recommend.
Rating: 5 via Google
Erik Shirk
3 years ago
They have great gluten free pizzas.
Rating: 4 via Google
Steven Marandola
3 years ago
The best pizza in Bellingham. Fresh local ingredients, great dough, but a mediocre sauce. The best and most amazing pepperoni rolls I've ever had. They beat anything on the east coast.
Rating: 5 via Google
Bryant Foster
3 years ago
Excellent ingredients sourced locally, bit on the pricy side but totally worth it.
Rating: 5 via Google
Jacqui MacT
3 years ago
Great pizza made with top quality, local, organic ingredients. Courteous service also!
Reviewer image
Pizza'zza replied:
Thanks so much for this review, Jacqui! We really appreciate it. See you in again soon. :-)
3 years ago
Rating: 1 via Google
Kay McClellan
3 years ago
Sorry, but when I call in an order and tell whoever it is I'm talking to that I have a coupon....(one by the way I just received a couple weeks ago, and NO expiration date), and this said person tells me the coupon is good, and I go ahead and order....I expect that when I go to pick up the pizza that the coupon will be honored. It was not. My son was told that they changed their system (what system I don't know) and they no longer accept this coupon. OK, why did the person I ordered the pizza from not tell me this??? They refused to honor it......My son was offered a 15% discount, far below what the coupon would have given us. Oh well, I'll never go there again, ever. As far as the taste.......it was OK. The crust was tough....really tough. So as far as Pizzazza goes, it's not on my list of places to go....sorry. You whoever is reading this might think otherwise.
Reviewer image
Pizza'zza replied:
Hi, Kay. I'm very sorry to hear about your experience. I would like to know more so that we can address this issue. You're coupon should have been honored, as that is our policy. I would like to find a way to refund your order, make it up to you, and make this right. Can you email me at erica@pizzazza.com or call me at 360.610.9231? Thank you for your feedback, Kay. Erica Co-Owner, Pizza'zza
3 years ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Anonymous
3 years ago
Haven't tried any of the pizza, but the tuna melt is to die for!
Reviewer image
Pizza'zza replied:
Thanks for this great review! Can't wait to hear from you when you try the pizza. We think it's to die for too! :-)
3 years ago
Rating: 2 via Google
Graham Johnson
3 years ago
Pizza is just OK. There are a lot of local and fresh toppings but the sauces leave a lot to be desired. The service I've received has been consistently bad.
Reviewer image
Pizza'zza replied:
Hi, Graham. I'm sorry to hear that you haven't enjoyed our pizza, and it sounds like the customer service you've received hasn't been up to our standards. Please email me at erica@pizzazza.com and tell me a little more about your customer service experiences so that we can address these issues directly and immediately with our staff. If you're willing to try our pizza again (perhaps with a different sauce this time?), let me know and I can send a gift card out to you. It is always our intent that you are completely satisfied with your Pizza'zza experience.
3 years ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Derek Long
25 days ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Mick Sheedy
1 month ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Will Middlebrooks
1 month ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Justin Martin
1 month ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Lisa Mahaffey
1 month ago
Rating: 4 via Google
Bradley Rabenstein
2 months ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Wendy Wixson
4 months ago
Rating: 5 via Google
David Gauthier
4 months ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Kyle Davis
5 months ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Barry Levenson
5 months ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Amber Bryson
5 months ago
Rating: 4 via Google
Jeff Cummings
5 months ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Jennifer Tietz
6 months ago
Rating: 5 via Google
June Parker
6 months ago
Rating: 4 via Google
Michael Singfield
6 months ago
Rating: 3 via Google
Salinwa
8 months ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Isaac Konikoff
8 months ago
Rating: 5 via Google
charles davis
8 months ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Jon Timmer
8 months ago
Rating: 4 via Google
austin jenkins
8 months ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Elena Rae
8 months ago
Rating: 1 via Google
Shawn Vess
8 months ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Katelyn Figaro
10 months ago
Rating: 1 via Google
Nicole coop
11 months ago
Reviewer image
Pizza'zza replied:
Nicole? The Nicole that used to work for us? Lol
11 months ago
Rating: 2 via Google
Rachael Sheffield
1 year ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Andrea Osborne
1 year ago
Rating: 4 via Google
Hunter Harlow
1 year ago
Rating: 5 via Google
matthew Ozgercin
2 years ago
Rating: 4 via Google
Nicholas Johnson
2 years ago
Rating: 1 via Google
Alan Clissold
2 years ago
Rating: 5 via Google
ValasVixson
2 years ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Arnold Gallows
2 years ago
Rating: 4 via Google
Patrick Reinhardt
2 years ago
Rating: 3 via Google
Ryan Schmidlkofer
3 years ago
Rating: 5 via Google
Andrew VanDriel
3 years ago
Reviewer image
Pizza'zza replied:
Thanks for the 5-star review, Andrew!! :-)
3 years ago